Discussion:
Smurffit ja kommunismi
(too old to reply)
A.S.
2007-01-09 01:18:59 UTC
Permalink
Wikipediasta otettu:

Smurfs and communism

Main article: The Smurfs and communism
It is now argued by some that Peyo meant to spread communist ideas
through smurf cartoons. [2] S.M.U.R.F. is translated by supporters of
this theory as "Socialist Men Under Red Father" or "Soviet Men Under
Red Father", however both of these theories disregard the fact that the
Smurfs' original name is "Schtroumpfs", "Smurf" being merely a
translation after the fact. The Red Father in the cartoon is Papa
Smurf, who wears a red hat and trousers. It is also noted that Papa
Smurf might be a representation of Karl Marx because of his similar
looking beard.

An analysis of the symbolism of the smurfs also can point to that
theory. Smurfs live in a village with rules similar to that of a
communist society including sharing of everything by everyone, absence
of currency, equality (symbolized by similar clothing), everyone more
or less serving a functional and necessary purpose in the community,
etc. Gargamel is said to represent capitalism with particular emphasis
being made on his greediness, especially his desire to transform the
smurfs into gold.
T.K.H.
2007-01-09 01:22:22 UTC
Permalink
Post by A.S.
Smurfs and communism
Main article: The Smurfs and communism
It is now argued by some that Peyo meant to spread communist ideas
through smurf cartoons. [2] S.M.U.R.F. is translated by supporters of
this theory as "Socialist Men Under Red Father" or "Soviet Men Under
Red Father", however both of these theories disregard the fact that the
Smurfs' original name is "Schtroumpfs", "Smurf" being merely a
translation after the fact. The Red Father in the cartoon is Papa
Smurf, who wears a red hat and trousers. It is also noted that Papa
Smurf might be a representation of Karl Marx because of his similar
looking beard.
An analysis of the symbolism of the smurfs also can point to that
theory. Smurfs live in a village with rules similar to that of a
communist society including sharing of everything by everyone, absence
of currency, equality (symbolized by similar clothing), everyone more
or less serving a functional and necessary purpose in the community,
etc. Gargamel is said to represent capitalism with particular emphasis
being made on his greediness, especially his desire to transform the
smurfs into gold.
http://www.iamlost.com/features/smurfs/commies.shtml
Heikki Heinonen
2007-01-09 10:14:44 UTC
Permalink
Post by A.S.
Main article: The Smurfs and communism
It is now argued by some that Peyo meant to spread communist ideas
through smurf cartoons. [2] S.M.U.R.F. is translated by supporters of
this theory as "Socialist Men Under Red Father" or "Soviet Men Under
Red Father", however both of these theories disregard the fact that the
Smurfs' original name is "Schtroumpfs", "Smurf" being merely a
translation after the fact. The Red Father in the cartoon is Papa
Smurf, who wears a red hat and trousers. It is also noted that Papa
Smurf might be a representation of Karl Marx because of his similar
looking beard.
Mutta nehän elää niinkuin munkit luostarissaan. Naisiakaan ei juuri ole. Papa
Smurf viittaisi selvästi katolilaisuuteen, koska paaviakin sanotaan papaksi.
Jukka Koivusaari
2007-01-09 17:19:33 UTC
Permalink
Post by Heikki Heinonen
Post by A.S.
Main article: The Smurfs and communism
It is now argued by some that Peyo meant to spread communist ideas
through smurf cartoons. [2] S.M.U.R.F. is translated by supporters of
this theory as "Socialist Men Under Red Father" or "Soviet Men Under
Red Father", however both of these theories disregard the fact that the
Smurfs' original name is "Schtroumpfs", "Smurf" being merely a
translation after the fact. The Red Father in the cartoon is Papa
Smurf, who wears a red hat and trousers. It is also noted that Papa
Smurf might be a representation of Karl Marx because of his similar
looking beard.
Mutta nehän elää niinkuin munkit luostarissaan. Naisiakaan ei juuri ole. Papa
Smurf viittaisi selvästi katolilaisuuteen, koska paaviakin sanotaan papaksi.
Mutta niillä on siniset paidat , niinkuin DDRän stallareilla.

--
"Ah , Anckarströmejäkö olettekin "
-JK
http://www.kolumbus.fi/jik
Heikki Heinonen
2007-01-10 00:07:53 UTC
Permalink
On Tue, 9 Jan 2007 19:19:33 +0200, "Jukka Koivusaari"
Post by Heikki Heinonen
Post by Heikki Heinonen
Post by A.S.
Main article: The Smurfs and communism
It is now argued by some that Peyo meant to spread communist ideas
through smurf cartoons. [2] S.M.U.R.F. is translated by supporters of
this theory as "Socialist Men Under Red Father" or "Soviet Men Under
Red Father", however both of these theories disregard the fact that the
Smurfs' original name is "Schtroumpfs", "Smurf" being merely a
translation after the fact. The Red Father in the cartoon is Papa
Smurf, who wears a red hat and trousers. It is also noted that Papa
Smurf might be a representation of Karl Marx because of his similar
looking beard.
Mutta nehän elää niinkuin munkit luostarissaan. Naisiakaan ei juuri ole.
Papa
Post by Heikki Heinonen
Smurf viittaisi selvästi katolilaisuuteen, koska paaviakin sanotaan
papaksi.
Mutta niillä on siniset paidat , niinkuin DDRän stallareilla.
Siniset paidat ja valkoiset pipot viittaa selvästi Israeliin ja sen lippuun.
Jospa piirtäjällä oli mielessään jonkinlainen kibbutsi.
Otto J. Makela
2007-01-10 08:17:34 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jukka Koivusaari
Post by Heikki Heinonen
Mutta nehän elää niinkuin munkit luostarissaan. Naisiakaan ei
juuri ole. Papa Smurf viittaisi selvästi katolilaisuuteen, koska
paaviakin sanotaan papaksi.
Mutta niillä on siniset paidat , niinkuin DDRän stallareilla.
Paidat? Smurffithan ovat sarjakuva-ankkojen komplementtijoukko koska
siinä missä ankoilla ei ole housuja, heillä ei ole paitoja.

Loading Image...
--
/* * * Otto J. Makela <***@iki.fi> * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * */
/* Phone: +358 40 765 5772, FAX: +358 42 7655772, ICBM: 60N 25E */
/* Mail: Mechelininkatu 26 B 27, FI-00100 Helsinki, FINLAND */
/* * * Computers Rule 01001111 01001011 * * * * * * * * * * * * */
George Saraiste Jr.
2007-01-11 00:53:25 UTC
Permalink
Smurffithan ovat sarjakuva-ankkojen komplementtijoukko.
Jep.
Kuulin, että Disneylandiin ei pääse smurffi-T-paita yllä.
:)

Mutta, mutta... asiasta kolmanteen...
Muistahan seuraavan kerran mainita asettamistasi follareista.
Kuuluu hyvään nettietikettiin. Eiks je?
:-/

[sfnet.keskustelu.uskonto pudotettu jatkoista]

Loading...